Wednesday, January 08, 2014

Part 3. Recent Internet Dialogue on Seldonian Dialectical Arithmetic: Edited Excerpt from Transcript.









Dear Reader,


Below I have posted an edited excerpt from the third part of a recent web forum thread dialogue on
F.E.D. dialectics in which I participated.

 
I have once again notated my interlocutor's queries by '
Q#.:', and my responses by 'R#.:'.

 
Please feel free to join in this dialogue here, by posting a query or comment via the Comment function of this blog.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

For more information regarding these Seldonian insights, please see --

 

www.dialectics.info

 

 

 

 

 



For partially pictographical, ‘poster-ized’ visualizations of many of these Seldonian insights -- specimens of ‘dialectical art’ – as well as illustrated books by the F.E.D. Press, see --


https://www.etsy.com/shop/DialecticsMATH

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

¡ENJOY!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Regards,

 

 

Miguel Detonacciones,

 

Voting Member, Foundation Encyclopedia Dialectica [F.E.D.];

Elected Member, F.E.D. General Council;

Participant, F.E.D. Special Council for Public Liaison;

Officer, F.E.D. Office of Public Liaison.

 

 

 

 

YOU are invited to post your comments on this blog-entry below!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



Q3.a.:  You wrote:

"Goods/Gifts exchange-relations x Goods/Gifts exchange-relations =

Goods/Gifts exchange-relations + Commodity Barter exchange-relations."


A lot of what you focus on seems to about the self-interaction of things, but is that not an idealist conception of Marx' materialism?



R3.a.:  I do not see what you mean by seemingly equating "the self-interaction of things" with "an idealist conception of Marx' materialism".

The emphasis on "self-interaction" is, besides being accurate to objective reality, also an antidote to the rampant externalism of many mechanistic and reductionistic mis-readings of Marx's theory. Marxian dialectics is not, primarily, a science of "external contradictions" -- of external "conflicts"; of entities/forces, mis-conceived as existing in mutual, atomistic independence and separately-subsistent mutual externality.

Marx and Engels make it plain, in their writings, that their dialectics is primarily a matter of internal "contradictions", of self-contradictions, of immanent contradictions, of the "self-change" [<<auto-kinesis>>], of the 'self-action', of the 'intra-action', that drive the 'self-evolution'-and-'self-meta-evolution' ['ontological self-revolution'] of natural [ev]entities, both those of pre-human Natural History, and those of 'human-Nature-al History', as well as those of contemporary 'extra-human Natural History'.

For example, it is the 'self-duality', the 'intra-duality' of a main sequence star -- the diametric opposition, within every single 'micro-locus' of its interior, of its 'self-gravitational self-implosive self-force', and its 'self-explosive thermonuclear/nucleosynthetic self-force' -- that even allows such a star to persist in existence for more than a few microseconds, that drives the 'self-evolutions' and the 'self-meta-evolutions' of such stars, in part, before, during, and, in part, also after its residence in stellar "main sequence" status, and that also drives the main part of cosmological atomic evolution, eventually populating the intra-galactic inter-stellar media of galaxies with the full periodic-table ontology of the "atoms" cosmo-ontological category, and laying the groundwork for cosmological molecular evolution and beyond.


For example
, it is the 'self-duality', the 'intra-duality' of the capitalist system -- of the working class versus the capitalist ruling class, of variable capital versus constant capital/the rest of capital within the production process, within "productive capital", of capital versus capital itself as self-expropriator, as 'fetters-on-the-growth-of-the-productive-forces-destroyer' --

capital as self-expanding value # capital as self-contracting value [e.g., due to obsolescence depreciation and enforced write-off of old vintage fixed capital due to competition from new vintage fixed capital, incarnating the growth of the social forces of production], using '#' as the sign for the relation of dialectical, internal, immanent, self-"contradiction"

-- that drives the self-evolution, and the 'self-meta-evolution' [the 'socio-ontological self-revolution'], of the capitalist system, as a transiently necessary but transitory form, an equally-necessarily self-transcending form, or else human-species-'self-extinctioning' form, of the collective life-process and life-<<praxis>> of an emerging planetary humanity as, consciously and unconsciously, the collective subject/agent of planetary human history.

In any case, Marx's materialism is no crude, reductionist 'matter-ism':  even [surplus-]value, the primary category of Marx's critique of capitalist political-economics, refers, not to a purely physical thing, but a human intersubjective construct, projected, by humans, collectively, 'consensually', onto social things, and an objectively lawful object of scientific study because humans collectively tend to act, to behave, all but unanimously, as if their value-construct were an entirely external-to-mind, physical thing, during a certain, historically-specific epoch of their "prehistory" [Marx]. 

Marx's materialism is a 'psychohistorical materialism', a materialism that -- scientifically and objectively -- takes the "materiality" of the human psyche, of the products of the human mind, of ideologies and of sciences, of "universal labor", of the influence of those mind-products, of those "memes", of that 'idea-matter', of that 'subject-matter/agent-matter', on human-societal action.





Q3.b.:  For example, here you talk about commodity exchange relations emerging from the self-interaction of simple goods/gifts exchange relations, but it seems obvious to me that such a transition involved a lot more than the self-interaction of a specific thing or relationship in itself, artificially isolated from the external world, other things and other relationships."



R3.b.:  First of all, let me now clearly state that we use human, socio-ontological category-names, like 'the Goods-/Gifts-Relation' and 'The Commodity Barter-Relation', in the same way that Marx uses his phrases "The Commodity-Relation", and "The Money-Relation", and "The Capital-Relation" -- namely, to name human "social relations of production", that are the social masks of real human subjects, real human agents, real human persons, who are constrained to, precisely, "personify" [Marx's term] these "social relations of production", when those persons exist in the context of certain, historically-specific human social formations.

Of course, more is always involved in such transitions than is explicitly asserted by such category-names.

However, the Genomic cognitive limitations of human beings are such that we cannot hold in mind all that is involved in even everyday processes, in detail, with even all of the limited specifics that our limited Genomic sensoria can record, represented mentally all in explicit form.

Especially with regard to human social processes, as Marx wrote, in the very Preface to the very First German edition of Capital, abstraction is an essential instrumentality: "In the analysis of economic forms, moreover, neither microscopes nor chemical reagents are of use.  The force of abstraction must replace both."

But these -- inherently omissive -- abstractions must therefore be selected/developed because they are rational abstractions, apt abstractions, if they are to qualify as valid, scientific abstractions, or as scientific "idealizations".  They must be abstractions that capture the core of the phenomenology explicitly, and that capture even more than that core connotatively, implicitly, as a subliminal reminder as to what they leave out of explicitude.

Marx held that his key explanatory categories -- of "the social forces of production" and the "social relations of production" -- qualified as such scientific abstractions. 

We agree.























Saturday, January 04, 2014

Part 2 of Recent Internet Dialogue on Seldonian Dialectical Algebra.











Dear Reader,



Below I have posted an edited excerpt from the second part of a recent web forum thread dialogue on F.E.D. dialectics in which I participated.

 
I have once again notated my interlocutor's queries by 'Q#.:', and my responses by 'R#.:'.

 
Please feel free to join in this dialogue here, by posting a query or comment via the Comment function of this blog.



Regards,

Miguel




 




 

Q2.:


thesis x antithesis = synthesis.


I get that.


But then what?


What can be derived from this??






R2.: From this, we can construct a Universal Method, called ‘‘‘The Dialectical Method’’’, whereby theories -- explaining the pasts, and predicting the futures -- of the “totalities”, i.e., of the “systems” of phenomena, that we encounter and experience, can be, first, discovered, and then presented systematically, and then mnemonically retained / remembered, via an ultimate degree of knowledge representation compression, that is readily -- intuitively and algorithmically -- re-expandable.

Discovering and then sharing/disseminating such a dialectical-scientific theory, of/for such a totality, involves discovering and organizing the categories that can “comprehend” the experienced, empirical content of that totality, i.e., that can comprehensively organize the entire content of all of the experiential, phenomenal entities that make up that totality, in terms of the various qualities of the various sub-groups of those entities, and discovering the progression or progressive order of those categories -- how those categories tie together; how one category “begets” another, in a kind of ‘categorial meta-genealogy’-- and then presenting those categories, presenting their categorial progression, i.e., their ‘meta-genealogy’ -- orally, and/or in writing, systematically.

By such a “systematic” presentation, I mean one which, presents the categories that “comprehend” the given totality, starting from the simplest category of the given totality, then moving on to present the next more complex category, then to the next, still more complex category after that -- in monotonic order of rising complexity -- until the richest, most explanatorily powerful, most complex category “comprehending” that totality is reached/achieved, and presented, which should also be the intuitive order of the connexions between one category and the next.

The Seldon arithmetic and algebra of for dialectics gives heuristic, algorithmic support to these intuitive processes of theory discovery/formation, theory presentation, and mnemonic theory retention. Here’s how.


To discover/present/retain such dialectical-scientific theories, for most of the key totalities, we need, first, to get beyond a mere three categories, i.e., beyond --

thesis category + antithesis category + synthesis category

-- to as many categories, in dialectical categorial progression, as we need to “comprehend” / explain the given totality.

So let us broaden our terminology, to accommodate names for more than just the first three categories of generic dialectics.

For the “dyadic” Seldon function version of the general dialectic, the fundamental rules are the following --

thesis x thesis = thesis + antithesis

antithesis x thesis = thesis + synthesis

-- which we can broaden, to accommodate any number of additional, higher antitheses and syntheses, as follows:

first thesis x first thesis = first thesis + first antithesis

first antithesis x first thesis = first thesis + first synthesis.


So that we get a progression, by “squaring” each result, i.e., by “interacting” every component of our result with itself, and with every other components), that looks like this --

point-of-departure: first thesis

first thesis squared with itself = first thesis x first thesis = first thesis + first antithesis;

(first thesis + first antithesis ) squared = (first thesis + first antithesis) x (first thesis + first antithesis) =

(first thesis x first thesis) +
(first thesis x first antithesis) +
(first antithesis x first thesis) +
(first antithesis x first antithesis) = [highlighting the new]:

(first thesis + first antithesis) +
(first antithesis + first synthesis) +
(first thesis + first synthesis) +
(first antithesis + second antithesis)

-- which, taking out parentheses, becomes --

first thesis + first antithesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + first thesis + first synthesis + first antithesis + second antithesis.


Now, removing redundant occurrences of generic dialectical categories from the above, i.e., removing all but the first appearance of each category, we get --

first thesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + second antithesis.


If we again “square” this result with itself, and again eliminate redundant occurrences of categories, we get --

(first thesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + second antithesis) squared =

(first thesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + second antithesis) x (first thesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + second antithesis) =

first thesis + first antithesis + first synthesis + second antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second synthesis + third antithesis.


We can broaden are terminology again, to make the whole terminology jibe with the emergence of “partial syntheses” as follows --

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis.




If we think of the “first_thesis”, or “thesis_#1”, as representing, in effect “full_synthesis_#0”, then the following system of two, coupled, dialectical-algebraic equations is general for the dyadic Seldon function version of generic or general dialectics -- i.e., for dyadic Seldon function generated, generic dialectical categorial progressions:


full_antithesis_#N x full_antithesis_#N = full_antithesis_#N + full_antithesis_#N+1

&

full_antithesis_#N+1 x full_synthesis_#N = full_synthesis_#N + full_synthesis_#N+1.




[The corresponding system of two, coupled, dialectical-algebraic equations for the general triadic Seldon function version of generic or general dialectics -- i.e., for triadic Seldon function generated, generic dialectical categorial progressions -- is the following:


full synthesis_#N x full synthesis_#N   =   (full synthesis_#N)^2   =

full synthesis_#N + full_antithesis_#N+1

&

full_antithesis_#N+1 x full_synthesis_#N   =   full_synthesis_#N + full_synthesis_#N+1.

 

The expansion of the generic-dialectical triadic Seldon function through its first nine terms is --

 

first_thesis^(3^2)  =   first_thesis^9 =

first_thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + first partial antithesis + second partial antithesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis ].






I should note, here, that we often find ourselves moved to use what seem to us to be more pertinent generic dialectical category names than those involving “thesis”, “antithesis”, and “synthesis”, when expressing the content stated otherwise above.

The terms “thesis”, “antithesis”, and “synthesis” bespeak “theses” as propositions -- e.g., as in the exchange of propositions and of counter-propositions [and of synthesizing ‘uni-propositions’] in a dialogue among two or more voices/persons, or as in the internal, e.g., inaudible, unspoken ‘self-dialogue’ of the thought-process within the mind of a single person.




Indeed, such were the historical origins, and contexts, and the original meanings, and the etymology, of the word «dialektikê».






However, for the context of “systematic dialectics” -- i.e., of systematically-ordered categorial progressions, describing and explaining the present organization and reproduction of a given totality, we find the following nomenclature more pertinent:

chosen starting category + first full contra-category + first full uni-category + second full contra-category + first partial uni-category + second partial uni-category + second full uni-category + third full contra-category . . ..


On the other hand, for the context of “historical dialectics” -- i.e., of chronologically-ordered categorial progressions, describing /- reconstructing, and explaining, the past historical progression of a whole historical sequence of different, successive physical totalities, especially for pre-human, ‘pre-mental’, ‘‘‘pre-cognitive’’’, ‘pre-«psychê»-ic’ totalities of the overall dialectic of Nature, we find the following nomenclature more pertinent, given the meaning of the ancient Greek word -- the fact, the principle, the pattern of self-growth in Nature:

chosen starting «physis» + first full meta-«physis» + first full uni-«physis» + second full meta-«physis» + first partial uni-«physis» + second partial uni-«physis» + second full uni-«physis» + third full meta-«physis». . ..




Whereas, for the context of “historical dialectics” involving human, ‘‘‘mental’’’, ‘‘cognitive’’, ‘«psychê»-ic’ totalities of the overall dialectic of Nature, and building on the word ‘‘‘meme’’’, we find the following nomenclature more pertinent, given the meaning of the ancient term ‘‘‘meme’’’, and forming, from it, the neologism ‘memesis’ to name the expression of any system of memes, all the way up to and including a cultural totality, an historically specific cultural/ideological “superstructure”, an epoch in the ‘meta-evolution’ of ‘Phenome’ of the total human species:

chosen starting memesis + first full contra-memesis + first full uni-memesis + second full contra-memesis + first partial uni-memesis + second partial uni-memesis + second full uni-memesis + third full contra-memesis . . ..





We can always go on, if need be, by again squaring these sums of eight categories, variously ‘nomenclatured’ above, each with itself, and by then re-squaring that squaring, and so on, to some indefinite ultimate extent, e.g., until we have all of the generic dialectical categories we need for the given specific dialectical modeling application thereof.



But, instead, let’s stay with this eight-category stage of generic dialectics, and consider some specific examples of this generic dialectic.





Example 1. Let’s consider, first, the classic example of scientific dialectics, the theory, and the presentation of the theory, of capitalism, in Marx’s magnum opus, Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. In that work Marx is not, primarily, presenting the historical dialectic leading from primitive communism, through the progression of class societies, ending with capitalism, and on to higher, democratic communism [as distinguished from, e.g., Stalinist, plutocratic state-capitalism]. Instead, he is taking a cross-section of historical time, the present representative “slice” of history, that contains only contemporary capitalist class society, e.g., mainly in the U.K. of his time, and presenting, systematically, the categories that account for/explain the present, temporary self-reproduction of this capitalist system.

Let us limit ourselves to the forms of [exchange-]value categories that Marx includes, and that manifest primarily in the circulation process of capitals, not trying to cover, in this initial “dialectical model” of the content of Marx’s treatise, the categories that manifest primarily in the production process of capitals, in order to keep this first example model a little simpler than it would otherwise have to be..

These categories of capitalist class society only encounter or encompass the past slice(s) of historical time, that contained its predecessor system(s) of class society, before that capitalist slice of history, and the predicted future slice(s) of historical time, after the predicted, self-non-reproduction, or self-«aufheben» self-negation, of the capitalist system, only at the two, opposite margins/ends of their representative “slice” -- only at the beginnings and at the ends of their categorial progression -- of the categorial progression that comprehends capitalism / the capitalist “slice” of history.


This kind of dialectics is called “systematic dialectics”, or ‘synchronic dialectics’, as [dialectically] opposed to “historical dialectics”, or ‘diachronic dialectics’.


Marx divides his work into an overall thesis category + antithesis category + synthesis category 'content-structure' --


thesis: vol. I -- “The Productions-process of Capitals” [German: «Der Produktionsprocess des Kapitals»], qP;

antithesis: vol. II -- “The Circulations-process of Capitals” [German: «Der Cirkulationsprocess des Kapitals»], qC;

synthesis: vol. III -- ‘‘‘The Process of Capital-Reproduction as a Whole’’’, qCP


-- a dialectic whereby we can symbolize the content of the whole work as --


qP + qC + qCP


-- wherein ‘q’ stands for a qualitative category, by way of the quality, shared by all of the entities or individual things/phenomena “comprehended” by any given category, and wherein qP stands for the totality of capitalist “Production” phenomena, and wherein qC stands for the totality of capitalist “Circulation” phenomena, and wherein qCP stands for the phenomena which combine and bind and integrate the Circulation and the Production phenomena together, into a “complex unity” or “synthesis” -- into a whole -- which constitutes the “Capitalist System” as a totality, and wherein the underscore, _, under the q, signifies the ‘contra-Boolean’ character of the arithmetical, algorithmic behavior of qX, whatever particular quality-name the symbol ‘X’ may abbreviate, i.e., the ‘contra-Boolean’ character of the addition and multiplication behaviors of qX.


Suppose we therefore take the category of “commodities” -- from Capital, volume I., Part I. [entitled “COMMODITIES AND MONEY”], Chapter I., entitled, simply, “Commodities”, as our special case of the generic “first thesis”.

We then have the following application of generic dialectics to model our specific part of dialectic of Capital:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms of the ‘“value-forms”’ Marx’s Capital theory, becomes --

commodities + monies + monies-mediated Circulations of commodities + «kapitals» + commodity-«kapitals» + money-«kapitals» + The Circulations of the Total Social «kapital» + portents of the developing Dialectical Self-Negation of the «kapitals»-System

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qc + qcc [ = qm ] + qmc + qmm [ = qk ]+ qkc + qkm + qkmc + qkk =

qc + qm + qmc + qk + qkc + qkm + qkmc + qkk

-- such that --

(1) the first thesis category symbol, qc, stands for the multitude of individual commodities that inhere in this, our present, Capitalist, social totality, and for the content of Capital, volume I, Part I, Chapter I.;

(2) the first full antithesis category symbol, qm, stands for the multitude of individual units of monies that inhere in our present social totality, and for the content of Capital, volume I, Part I, Chapter I., Section 3., D., wherein monies are grasped, ‘meta-genealogically’, as qcc -- as ‘meta-commodities, each one made up out of a heterogeneous multiplicity of commodities -- as a mental list, or meme, of the kinds of commodities whose owners will exchange them for monies [not a universal list at the earlier stages of commodity/money confrontation, and not a universal list of all “commodities” even today!];

(3) the first full synthesis category symbol, qmc, stands for the multitude of individual transactions, involving both Monies and Commodities, combined, as a “complex unity” process of “the monies-mediated circulations of commodities”, that inhere in our present social totality, and that Marx symbolized as C-M-C’, and for the content of Capital, volume I, Part I, Chapter III., Section 3., “...the Circulation of Commodities”;

(4) the second full antithesis category symbol, qk, stands for the multitude of individual «kapitals» that inhere in our present, Capitalist, social totality, and for the content of Capital, volume I, Part II, Chapter IV., “...the Circulation of Commodities”, whereby «kapitals» are grasped, ‘meta-genealogically’, as qmm -- as ‘meta-monies, each one made up out of a multiplicity of monies -- as a mental listing / accounting record / accounting sum meme, of the net profits, or retained earnings, and of the other net current assets [net “Equity”] over the whole history, to-date, of the past accounting periods, or aggregate transactions, during the existence of each given individual «kapital» thereby represented;

(5) the first partial synthesis category symbol, qkc, stands for the multitude of those portions of individual units of «kapital» that presently, temporarily take the form of multitudes of commodities, thus units of commodities and of «kapitals» combined, as a “complex unity”, named, by Marx, “Commodity-Capital”, that inhere in our present society, and that constitute a partial synthesis category because qkc unifies the categories of qk and qc, but without also unifying them with the other already extant/already presented category, qm. The symbol qkc also stands for the content of Capital, volume II, Part I, Chapter III., “the Circuit of Commodity-Capital”;

(6) the second partial synthesis category symbol, qkm, stands for the multitude of portions of individual units of «kapital» that presently, momentarily take the form of multitudes of monies, thus units of monies and of «kapitals» combined, as a “complex unity”, named, by Marx, “Money-Capital”, that inhere in our present society, and that constitute a partial synthesis category because qkm unifies the categories of qk and qm, but without also unifying them with the other already extant/already presented category, qc. The symbol qkm also stands for the content of Capital, volume II, Part I, Chapter I., “the Circuit of Money-Capital”;

(7) the third full synthesis category symbol, qkmc, stands for the multitude of presently existing portions of each individual unit of «kapital» that presently, transiently take the form of a multitude of money units, qkm, on the way to ‘metamorphosizing’ into a multitude of units of commodities, qkc, on the way toward then re-‘metamorphosizing’ into a multitude of units of Monies, qkm, and for the multitude of presently existing portions of each individual unit of «kapital» that presently, transiently take the form of a multitude of individual commodity units, qkc, on the way to ‘metamorphosizing’ into a multitude of money units, qkm, on the way toward then re-‘metamorphosizing’ into a multitude of units of commodities, qkc, but combined, as a “complex unity”, named, by Marx, ‘“The Circulations-Process of the Total Social Capital”, by which kapital, qk, appropriates, to itself, the “money mediated circulation of commodities” , qmc, and, equally, the “commodities-mediated circulation of monies” , qcm -- via, e.g., qkmc = qk x qmc, minus qmc -- that inheres in our present society, and that constitutes a full synthesis category because qkmc unifies all three categories -- qk, qm, and qc -- that are already extant/already presented, so far, in this categorial progression. The category-symbol qkmc also stands for the content of Capital, volume II, Part III, “THE REPRODUCTION AND CIRCULATION OF THE AGGREGATE SOCIAL CAPITAL”;

(8) the third full synthesis category symbol, qkk, stands for the multitude of processes of interaction among different individual «kapitals» -- that drive the competition of capitals, the expropriation of many «kapitals» by single «kapitals», the consolidation, concentration, and centralization of «kapitals», the accumulation of «kapitals», the rise in the organic composition of «kapitals», the tendency of the rate of profit on those «kapitals» to fall, and global economic crises of increasing severity -- that inhere in our present, Capitalist, social totality, and that drive its internal evolution toward the limits of the «kapitals»-system, and towards the possible birth, from out of its womb, of a higher human social system/totality, and thus also portending the emergence of some kind of ‘meta-«kapital(s)»’ [ev]entity. The category-symbol qkk also stands for the content of Capital, volume I, Part VII, “THE ACCUMULATION OF CAPITAL”, Chapter XXV., Section 3., “Progressive Production of a Relative Surplus-Population or Industrial Reserve Army”, of Part VII, “THE SO-CALLED PRIMITIVE ACCUMULATION”, Chapter XXXII., “Historical Tendency of Capitalist Accumulation”, of volume III, Part III, “THE LAW OF THE TENDENCY OF THE RATE OF PROFIT TO FALL”, and of volume III, Part V, Chapter XXVII., “The Role of Credit in Capitalist Production”.


[For those who understand “exponents” or “powers” of algebraic variables:]

This whole categorial-progression representation of Marxian knowledge can be condensed massively into just ten symbolic elements --

(qc)^(2^3), or into just six symbolic elements (qc)^8, or into just four symbolic elements c^8

-- the latter meaning ‘commodities^8’, in a way that can be re-expanded intuitively -- ‘re-minded’ -- into the full progression using the algorithm we have described above.





Reality is "everywhere dense" with dialectic.

Dialectical, [dynamical 'qualo-fractal'] 'content structures' are ubiquitous in Nature as a whole, and, '''holonomically''', independently, in its parts as well, in both re-constructed, past pre-human Nature, and in contemporary, extra-human Nature, as well as within the "artefacts" produced, and emerged within, and still emergent within, contemporary '''human Nature''', within 'The Human Phenome' of today.


Therefore, and thereby, we can also offer an abundance of simpler, more mundane, examples of such systematic dialectics [as well as of historical dialectics], e.g. --



Example 2. For the system of, e.g., English phonetic written language, starting category = letters [of the alphabet], we have the following application of generic dialectics to model the specific dialectic for this domain:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

letters + words + exceptions: single-letters-that-are-also-words [e.g. 'a' and 'I' [in Spanish, e.g., 'y']] + sentences + exceptions: single-letter-sentences + exceptions: single-word-sentences + exceptions: single-letters-that-are-also-single-words-that-are-also-sentences + paragraphs

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qL + qLL [ = qW ] + qWL + qWW [ = qS ]+ qSL + qSW + qSWL + qSS [ = qP ] =

qL + qW + qWL + qS + qSL + qSW + qSWL + qP
;



Example 3. For the system of, e.g., the English time metrology, starting category = seconds:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

seconds + minutes + intermediate durations, expressed in terms of both minutes and seconds + hours + intermediate durations, expressed in terms of hours plus seconds + intermediate durations, expressed in terms of hours plus minutes + intermediate durations, expressed in terms of hours plus minutes plus seconds + days

-- or, in our “shorthand” symbols --

qS + qSS [ = qM ] + qMS + qMM [ = qH ]+ qHS + qHM + qHMS + qHH [ = qD ] =

qS + qM + qMS + qH + qHS + qHM + qHMS + qD
;



Example 4. For the domain of contemporary TV Series, starting category = Episodes:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

Episodes + Seasons + exceptional, single Episode [e.g., cancelled early] Seasons + seRies + exceptional, single Episode seRies + single Season seRies + exceptional, single Season seRies which are also single Episode seRies + ‘Multi-seRies’ [e.g., StarTrek [original]; StarTrek The Next Generation; StarTrek Deep Space 9; Star Trek Voyager, StarTrek Enterprise; and, StarGate SG-1, StarGate Atlantis, StarGate Universe]

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qE + qEE [ = qS ] + qSE + qSS [ = qR ]+ qRE + qRS + qRSE + qRR [ = qM ] =

qE + qS + qSE + qR + qRE + qRS + qRSE + qM
;



Example 5. For the system of, e.g., American coinage, starting category = pennies:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

pennies + nickels + intermediate monetary amounts, expressed in terms of both nickels and pennies + dimes + intermediate “change” amounts, expressed in terms of dimes plus pennies + intermediate amounts, expressed in terms of dimes plus nickels + intermediate amounts, expressed in terms of dimes plus nickels plus pennies + quarter[-dollar]s

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qP + qPP [ = qN ] + qNP + qNN [ = qD ]+ qDP + qDN + qDNP + qDD [ = qQ ] =

qP + qN + qNP + qD + qDP + qDN + qDNP + qQ
;



Example 6. For the system of “positive”, or ‘proverse’, operations of ordinary arithmetic, starting category = addition:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

additions + multiplications + “distributions” of multiplications over additions [and of additions over multiplications] + exponentiations + exponentiations over additions + exponentiations over multiplications + exponentiations over multiplications and additions + ‘meta-exponentiations’ [e.g., the 3 in (qc)^(2^3) is a ‘meta-exponent’]

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qA + qAA [ = qM ] + qMA [ = qD ]+ qMM [ = qE ]+ qEA + qEM + qEMA + qEE =

qA + qM + qD + qE + qEA + qEM + qEMA + qEE
;



Example 7. For the system of “negative”, or ‘inverse’, operations of ordinary arithmetic, starting category = subtraction:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

subtractions [‘de-additions’] + divisions [‘multi-subtractions’; ‘de-multiplications’] + “combinations of division(s) and subtraction(s) + root-extractions [‘divisions of divisions’; ‘de-exponentiations’] + combinations of root extractions and subtractions + combinations of root-extraction(s) and division(s) + combinations of root-extraction(s) with both division(s) and subtraction(s) + ‘de-meta-exponentiations’ [e.g., the operation that ‘‘‘extracts’’’ 3 from (qc)^(2^3) is a ‘de-meta-exponentiation’]

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qS + qSS [ = qD ] + qDS + qDD [ = qR ]+ qRS + qRD + qRDS + qRR =

qS + qD + qDS + qR + qRS + qRD + qRDS + qRR
;




Example 8. For the system of, e.g., modern ‘computerware’ -- with the word ‘computerware’ standing for the category of the synthesis, or “complex unity”, of the categories “computer hardware” and “computer software” -- starting category = [binary] bits, we have the following application of generic dialectics to model the specific dialectic for this domain:

first thesis + first full antithesis + first full synthesis + second full antithesis + first partial synthesis + second partial synthesis + second full synthesis + third full antithesis

-- which, interpreted / specified in terms this specific domain, becomes --

bIts + bYtes + exceptions: one-bit bytes + computer words + exceptions: single-bit computer words + exceptions: single-byte computer words + exceptions: single-byte-computer-words-that-are-also-single-bit-computer-words + computer-language commands

-- or, via our “shorthand” symbols, which becomes --

qI + qII [ = qY ] + qYI + qYY [ = qW ]+ qWI + qWY + qWYI + qWW [ = qC ] =

qI + qY + qYI + qW + qWI + qWY + qWYI + qC
.





Next, I’ll give you some examples of dialectical-algebraic models for historical dialectics. . . ..



How much of this is clear to you, so far?

Please lodge additional queries as needed!











Wednesday, January 01, 2014

Recent Internet Dialogue on Seldonian Dialectical Arithmetic: Edited Excerpt from Transcript.



Dear Reader,

By this blog-entry let me also wish to you a very richly-lived and, thus, a very prosperous 2014 !!!


Below, for your cognitive enjoyment, I have posted an edited -- 'anonymized' -- excerpt from a recent web forum dialogue on F.E.D. dialectics in which I participated.

I have notated my interlocutor's queries by 'Q#.:', and my responses by 'R#.:'.

Please feel free to join in this dialogue here, by posting a query or comment via the Comment Function.


Regards,

Miguel




 

Q1.:  Thesis x antithesis = synthesis.

I get that.

But why is thesis x thesis = antithesis?

...it would really be great if you could explain it step by step. ...





R1.:  There are two "dialectical functions" that we use to build "dialectical models".

One is called "dyadic" because it expands by twos.

The other is called "triadic", because it expands by threes.


What I cited to you is from the '"convolute"' version of the "dyadic" function.


Its logic is opposite to that of Boole's algebra of logic.


In Boole's algebra of logic, you can never get anywhere new, in terms of the kinds of things that exist.


In Boole's original algebra of logic, you can only address the statical relations of inclusion versus of exclusion between one "class" ['''category'''] versus another, or define one class / category in terms of (an)other(s).


But no "new" classes / categories, "containing" NEW kinds of things -- new kinds of individuals -- can be born into the universe from interactions of the old, already existing kinds of things, or from their '''self-interactions''', and/or from the [self-]interactions of their classes / categories, within that universe[-of-discourse], in the original Boolean algebra model of that universe[-of-discourse] --


thesis x thesis = thesis

1 x 1 = 1

0 x 0 = 0.



This equation, thesis x thesis = thesis, class x class = class, category x category = category, is what Boole called "The Fundamental Law of Thought".

It is certainly NOT "The Fundamental Law of DIALECTICAL thought"!



Boole's "Fundamental Law of Thought" provides only for a "Simple Reproduction" of ideas/categories --

idea x idea = idea.



Dialectical logic needs to model a qualitatively, ontologically "[Self-]Expanding Reproduction" of ideas, and an "[Self-]Expanding Reproduction" of non-idea kinds of things, e.g., external-to-mind, physical things [although, of course, we "grasp" -- "hold" -- these physical things, in mind, and "language" about them, via ideas, via 'mind-things', via '''memes'''.  But our ideas of physical things refer to things that we hold to exist "objectively", outside of our minds.  Such ideas are not about "things" that exist ONLY in our minds, like, e.g., that idea-only-thing, that idea-unit, which is the unit[y] of the "Natural" Numbers, 1] --


idea x idea = idea + new/better idea.


physical-thing-kind_1 x physical-thing-kind_1 = physical-thing-kind_1 + physical-thing-kind_2.




There is no qualitative change, no ontological change, no ontological gain, per the Boolean model.





The algebra of a dialectical logic needs to model a universe in which new kinds of things regularly come into existence, from out of the interactions and '''self-interactions'''  among old kinds of things, i.e., in which ontological revolutions occur -- e.g., the first atomic clouds turned into "molecular clouds" as the quantitative growth and growing density of atoms gave birth to a new kind of things -- molecules -- or, e.g., as the growth of the human societal self-reproductive self-force gave birth to Commodity Barter social relations of production, once the societal "population" and societal "density" of Goods/Use-Values/Gifts exchange social relations of production crossed a critical historic[al] threshold.


Note that 'atoms x atoms = molecules' is not a good model here, because the atoms don't disappear entirely when the molecules first form, and also that 'atoms x atoms = atoms', the Boolean model, is also no good here, because it completely misses out on the first cosmological emergence of the new ontological category/class of "molecules".

We need --

atoms x atoms = atoms + molecules

--  '<<aufheben>>-ing' the Boolean "law", by "conserving" the 'Boolean moment' of 'atoms x atoms = atoms', but also dialectically, determinately "negating", and "elevating" that Boolean "law" by incorporating also the 'contra-Boolean moment' 'atoms x atoms = molecules', to form, as a whole, the Seldonian dialectical "law" of thought, and of physical actuality, namely --

atoms^2 = atoms + molecules

-- so that --

atoms^2 is NOT equal to atoms

-- indeed --

atoms^2 is qualitatively different from, is ontologically different from atoms^1.







Likewise --

Goods/Gifts exchange-relations x Goods/Gifts exchange-relations =

Commodity Barter exchange-relations

-- is not a good model here.

Goods/Gifts exchange-relations did not cease to exist after barter exchange-relations first came into existence -- indeed, Goods/Gifts exchange-relations have continued to exist, in modified forms, all the way up into the capitalist historical present!



We need, instead --


Goods/Gifts exchange-relations x Goods/Gifts exchange-relations =

Goods/Gifts exchange-relations + Commodity Barter exchange-relations.




In the dyadic function, in its fuller, '"evolute"' rendition [I presented only the simplest, '"convolute'', form before] --


thesis x thesis = thesis + antithesis


-- i.e., you keep what you had before, you <<aufheben>>-conserve the "Boolean moment", but you also get, together with the "Boolean moment", a second "moment", something new.

At the critical point of ontological revolution / qualitative change that is modeled by 'thesis x thesis': you get back the "thesis" category, but you also get the "anti-thesis" category with respect to that "thesis" category.


The process I described in my previous post starts with 'thesis x thesis = [thesis +] [first] antithesis', but, thereafter, it becomes 'antithesis x antithesis = antithesis + next antithesis.


That is, in the dyadic function and model, 'antithesis x antithesis = antithesis + new antithesis' means that each synthesis is "outflanked" by a new antithesis, a new antithesis that comes from out of the self-interaction of the previous antithesis, which was transcended by that synthesis.

In a sense, the first antithesis keeps recurring at ever higher levels, in qualitatively, ontologically new forms, superseding each new synthesis, that temporarily transcended each new antithesis, and which, each time, is resolved into/by a new synthesis, only to have that new synthesis outflanked again, from out of the immediately-previous antithesis.



In the triadic function, on the other hand, the fundamental equation is 'synthesis x synthesis = synthesis + new antithesis': it is each new synthesis itself that breaks itself out into a new antithesis, by way of the self-interaction of that synthesis.




Is all of this clear, so far?


If not, please lodge additional queries!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

For more information regarding these Seldonian insights, please see --

 

www.dialectics.info

 

 

 

 

 

For partially pictographical, ‘poster-ized’ visualizations of many of these Seldonian insights -- specimens of ‘dialectical art’ – as well as illustrated books published by the F.E.D. Press, see --

https://www.etsy.com/shop/DialecticsMATH

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

¡ENJOY!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Regards,

 

 

Miguel Detonacciones,

 

Voting Member, Foundation Encyclopedia Dialectica [F.E.D.];

Elected Member, F.E.D. General Council;

Participant, F.E.D. Special Council for Public Liaison;

Officer, F.E.D. Office of Public Liaison.

 

 

 

 

YOU are invited to post your comments on this blog-entry below!